Does Net Neutrality Inhibit Innovation?
Last Updated on Thursday, 22 October 2009 08:34
Written by dbhalling
Thursday, 22 October 2009 08:34
Any government restriction on how the internet can operate will by definition limit innovation. The FCC’s Net Neutrality proposal violates the “Rate Law of Innovation”, which states that rate of innovation is directly related to the number of elements that innovators have available to them. The Net Neutrality rule limits how many variables or elements that innovators have to innovate. See the Laws of Innovation for more information. All the major engineers who developed the internet are opposed to the FCC’s Net Neutrality rules. According to Andrew Orlowski, “Engineers fear rash legislation would inhibit the ability of systems engineers to improve latency and jitter issues needed to move data at speed.” See Mr. Orowski’s article for more information.
The FCC’s response is that all their proposed rules include the limitation “Subject to reasonable network management.” They argue this prevents the FCC from being overly onerous in the application of these rules. Of course, the catch is who gets to determine what is reasonable. If it is the internet providers, then the rules are meaningless, since they will clearly believe that their network management is reasonable. Thus, it is clear that the FCC intends that someone other than the internet providers, get to decide what is reasonable. We know from history this will be lawyers, special interest groups, and large corporations defining reasonable to meet their special interest at the expense of the owners of the network and the public in general.
In addition to limiting innovation, the Net Neutrality rules are widely seen as the first step in a “Fairness Doctrine” for the internet. The Fairness Doctrine, which applies to radio and television, has been used to stifle free speech in this country. The Fairness Doctrine will kill the value of the internet as an outlet to monitor and police the government.
There is no justification for the Net Neutrality rules, they will stifle innovation, and they will lead to a Fairness Doctrine for the internet.
- A Christmas Tale: ‘I Am My Brother’s Keeper’ – and How it Applied to Patents
- Long Term Economic Predictions 2011
- The Science of Economic Growth: Part 2
- The Science of Economic Growth: Part 1
- The History of Patent Damages
- Repeal of Sarbanes Oxley and Dodd Frank Proposed
- Justice Breyer: Patent Ignorance
- New Ex-Parte Appeals Rules from the USPTO
- Mark Twain’s Birthday: Thoughts on Patents
- US Brain Drain