State of Innovation

Patents and Innovation Economics

Farewell to Reality: Book Review

This book explores the state of modern physics and suggests that theoretical physics has passed over into fairy tales.  The author suggests that many of the models proposed by theoretical physicists today are untestable, not that they have not yet been tested, but they can never be tested.  These theories have become total disconnected from empirical evidence, i.e., reality, and therefore threaten the vary basis of science.  He shows that this has led to theoretical physicists providing a scientific veneer to theological arguments, particularly the strong anthtropic principle in cosmology.

This book is very well written and is probably the best overview of modern theoretical physics I have ever read.  The book starts out by providing the “standard” understanding of modern physics.  Then it proceeds to examine some of the problems in physics, starting with Newton’s gravity as force at a distance.  He examines some of the early debates about quantum mechanics and then moves onto the standard model of particle physics and cosmology.  However it is not until he gets to String Theory, M-Brane or M-Theory and related ideas.  In my opinion, the author gives most of these ideas in physics the benefit of the doubt.  The author is respectful and provides overwhelming arguments before he calls any particular model fairy tale physics.  This is an excellent book for anyone interested in these issues.

Now for my criticisms: the book’s vague development of what constitutes science, while perhaps generous to the ideas he is criticizing is hardly a rigorous statement of the foundations of science.  In part, this is because the author buys into a platonic view of reality.  Strangely enough many of the models he criticizes also are based on a platonic view of reality.  If his foundations of science were more closely aligned with those of the enlightenment his arguments would be strengthened and he would find the source of the problems started earlier in physics than the book portrays.  If you are interested how anti-enlightenment philosophical ideas caused physics to go off course leading to the problems today see Absurdities in Modern Physics: A Solution, by Paul Marmet.

This book is part of a growing chorus that modern physics has lost its way and therefore all of science has also.

Advertisements

October 28, 2014 - Posted by | Blog, physics | ,

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: