Article I, Section 8, Clause 8 of the United States Constitution states:
To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.
An inventor is a person who creates something new. With the Feinstein amendment voted down, S.23 now called “Invent America Act” changes the U.S. to a “First to File” country. This violates the Constitutional mandate. By changing our patent laws to a first to file rule, Congress is not securing the exclusive rights of inventors. It is taking rights from inventors and giving them the person who games the legal system most effectively – files first.
Congress cannot just ignore the definition of inventor. This is not Alice in Wonderland. The inventor is the person who first creates something. S.23, the “Invent America Act” is unconstitutional.
2 Comments »
Leave a Comment
- Quantitative Easing II is Working – Thanks Ben
- David Boundy’s Excellent Analysis of the First to File Issues
- Inventor on Why First-to-File is Bad for Small inventors
- Intellectual Property’s Great Fallacy: Another Rambling Diatribe for Open Source Marxist Utopia
- Senator Feinstein: First-Inventor-to-File a Ruse
- S.23 Patent Bill Unconstitutional
- Patent Reform: “First Inventor to File” Misleading
- Conservative Groups: Patent Reform Bill a Disaster for US
- Fundamentals of Economic Science: An Objectivist Approach
- Science or Religion: Environmental Doomsday Theories
- Déjà vu All Over Again: Undoing the Reagan Revolution
- Patent Deform Act of 2011: Approved by Senate Committee